Klassik-heute.de, Gerhard Pätzig: Künstlerische Qualität 9, Gesamteindruck 9. Gramophone Magazine, Stanley Sadie: "Patrick Gallois, principal flute of the Orchestre National de France, is a strong, accurate and rhythmic player, easily equal to the music’s technical demands, and with a good feeling for its expressive character, shading the slow movements sensitively. He plays the unaccompanied sonata in a rather improvisatory style. Kevin Mallon directs the Toronto Camerata with plenty of spirit and they play responsively. But I do think these concertos would sound better with period instruments; and Mallon would have been wise to forego the occasional spiccato bowing, which is alien to Carl Philipp, as surely is the pizzicato in the finale of the A minor work."