《姐姐的守护者》影评 Review of Sister's Keeper 32号

采蜜的茄子
2018-05-16 00:13:44
提示:这篇影评可能有剧透

《姐姐的守护者》是一部温情动人又带有一点悲伤甚至是绝望的电影,有着出任一辆的结局,更给观众留下了值得思考的问题。电影在亲情、家庭和爱的基础上,探讨在无法治愈的疾病面前,身为家人应该是要把我任何有可能的机会和方法去延长病人的生命,亦是顺应天命,不过度治疗,让病人平静的离去。

姐姐凯特从小就患有白血病,父母生下妹妹安娜的初衷就是为了从安娜身上获取能够挽救凯特生命的血液和细胞。但结果却是长大后的姐姐不愿意再以这种伤害妹妹身体健康的方式痛苦地活下去,要求妹妹拒绝给自己移植肾脏和把坚持治疗的妈妈告上法庭。妈妈崩溃、心痛的同时又对安娜感到自责愧疚。

不舍家人离去是人之常情,但用尽一切手段来让病人痛苦地或者又是否人道?这让我联想到了安乐死,这个带有很大正义的话题。安乐死是“谋杀”还是人道主义?是否应该被允许?我认为安乐死是对人性的尊重,在人无法承受身体上的病痛折磨,又无法改变时,与其让自己和家人都饱受折磨,不如潇洒离去。有尊严地死去也是人的权利,是应该得到尊重的。

几天前,澳大利亚以为104岁的科学家古道尔选择以安乐死来结束自己的生命,他说:“一个人在适当的时间选择死亡,这是

...
显示全文

《姐姐的守护者》是一部温情动人又带有一点悲伤甚至是绝望的电影,有着出任一辆的结局,更给观众留下了值得思考的问题。电影在亲情、家庭和爱的基础上,探讨在无法治愈的疾病面前,身为家人应该是要把我任何有可能的机会和方法去延长病人的生命,亦是顺应天命,不过度治疗,让病人平静的离去。

姐姐凯特从小就患有白血病,父母生下妹妹安娜的初衷就是为了从安娜身上获取能够挽救凯特生命的血液和细胞。但结果却是长大后的姐姐不愿意再以这种伤害妹妹身体健康的方式痛苦地活下去,要求妹妹拒绝给自己移植肾脏和把坚持治疗的妈妈告上法庭。妈妈崩溃、心痛的同时又对安娜感到自责愧疚。

不舍家人离去是人之常情,但用尽一切手段来让病人痛苦地或者又是否人道?这让我联想到了安乐死,这个带有很大正义的话题。安乐死是“谋杀”还是人道主义?是否应该被允许?我认为安乐死是对人性的尊重,在人无法承受身体上的病痛折磨,又无法改变时,与其让自己和家人都饱受折磨,不如潇洒离去。有尊严地死去也是人的权利,是应该得到尊重的。

几天前,澳大利亚以为104岁的科学家古道尔选择以安乐死来结束自己的生命,他说:“一个人在适当的时间选择死亡,这是他的自由,不是他人应该干涉的。”

爱与死亡不是博弈中的两方,死去不代表爱的消逝,活着也不一定是真正的爱。爱一个人可能就是在适当的时候放手,让大家都从伤病的痛苦中解脱出来,逝者安息,生者将爱放在心中努力生活。

Sister’s Keeper is an emotional but sad, even desperate movie, which is ended with a unexpected ending, leaving the audience with a question worth pondering. Based on the love and family, this movie discusses that in the face of incurable diseases, the patient’s family should grasp any possible opportunities and methods to delay the patient’s life, or give in to the destiny, saying goodbye to the patient without giving over-treating.

The elder sister, Kate, had leukemia since childhood. The reason why the parents gave birth to Anna is to obtain blood and cells from Anna to save Kate’s life. However, the grown-up Kate doesn’t want to live her life in this way, hurting her little sister’s health. Therefore, Kate asks Anna to refuse to transplant kidney and accuses their mother of hurting Anna’s health by using Anna’s body.

It is human nature to save family member’s life, but is it humane to use all the methods to make the patient alive painfully? This reminds me of euthanasia, a controversial topic. Is euthanasia the murder or humanism? Should it be allowed? I think euthanasia is a respect for humanity. When the patient can’t bear the physical pain and the medical doesn’t work, it is better to leave than to torture himself and his family. It is human right to die with dignity and this should be respected. Several days ago, a 104-year-old Austrian scientist,Goodall decided to end his life. He said, “One wants to be free to choose the death when the death is appropriate time.”

Love and death are not enemies, because death doesn’t mean the love is gone. Maybe love is to let him go when the time is appropriate, releasing everyone from the pain of disease. May the deceased rest in peace and the family live strong.

0
0

查看更多豆瓣高分电影电视剧

回应(0)

添加回应

姐姐的守护者的更多影评

推荐姐姐的守护者的豆列

了解更多电影信息

豆瓣正在热议

豆瓣
免费下载 iOS / Android 版客户端