震撼的是思维逻辑细节

wanda
2018-04-12 08:04:03
提示:这篇影评可能有剧透

地处伦敦,竟然还窝在家里刷电影,真是浪费青春!不过万幸,看电影的同时到底还动了动脑子,总不完全是just kill time.

电影说的是几个各个领域的教授运用各各自知识去验证一个说法的真伪。辩论的过程中最打动我的并不是知识对知识的博弈,尽管这个真的很厉害,而有点悲剧的是其中关于耶稣的一些内容并没有太懂,因为缺少背景知识的支撑。最让我震撼的是谈话中每一个逻辑思维的细节,生活的常识都是正确的,可经过推敲的,这才是故事真正能让人信服的最重要的基础。

(以下是电影对白,X代表众多guest中的一个,J即是男主角John)

先从基本的常识开始。

13:21

J: Every ten years or so, when people start to notice I don't age, I move on.

然后开始个体认知。逻辑合理,因为自己并不知道自己是谁,名字都是未来研究的人给起。

13:38

X: So you think that you are a Cro-magnon.

J: Well, I didn't learn it in school. That's my best guess. Based on archaeological data, maps, anthropological research. Since mesopotamia, I've got the last 4,000 years straight.

自我介绍

...
显示全文

地处伦敦,竟然还窝在家里刷电影,真是浪费青春!不过万幸,看电影的同时到底还动了动脑子,总不完全是just kill time.

电影说的是几个各个领域的教授运用各各自知识去验证一个说法的真伪。辩论的过程中最打动我的并不是知识对知识的博弈,尽管这个真的很厉害,而有点悲剧的是其中关于耶稣的一些内容并没有太懂,因为缺少背景知识的支撑。最让我震撼的是谈话中每一个逻辑思维的细节,生活的常识都是正确的,可经过推敲的,这才是故事真正能让人信服的最重要的基础。

(以下是电影对白,X代表众多guest中的一个,J即是男主角John)

先从基本的常识开始。

13:21

J: Every ten years or so, when people start to notice I don't age, I move on.

然后开始个体认知。逻辑合理,因为自己并不知道自己是谁,名字都是未来研究的人给起。

13:38

X: So you think that you are a Cro-magnon.

J: Well, I didn't learn it in school. That's my best guess. Based on archaeological data, maps, anthropological research. Since mesopotamia, I've got the last 4,000 years straight.

自我介绍。此处大众的恐惧心理和早起社会的迷信。

14:00

J: What I called my first liftime, I aged to about 35 which is what you see. I ended up leading my group. They saw me as magical. I didn't even have to fight for it. Then fear came, and they chased me away. They thought that I was stealing their lives away to stay young.

自述与反问。关于时间的定义和记忆的解释。

14:25

J: The first thousand year, I didn't know up from sideways.

X: How do you know the first thousand years?

J: An informed guess, based on what I've learned in my memories.

X: Most people can scarcely remember their childhood, but you have memories of that time?

J: Like yours, selective. You know, the high points, the low points, traumas. They stick in the mind forever. Put down at 3 or 35, you still feel a twinge.

话题进入到各个历史时期的客观环境。问答机智。

15:08

J: ……The first 2,000 years were cold. We learned it was warmer at lower elevations. Late glacial period, I assume.

X: What was the terrain like?

J: Mountains. Vast plains to the west.

X: West. Something you learned in school.

J: Towards the setting sun ……

最震撼我的一点。完美解释了知识和记忆的关系。早起没有知识,记忆也没有。只有拥有知识才能唤起和印证记忆。

15:50

X1: So far, what he says fits.

X2: Oh, yeah, into any textbook.

J: And that's where I found it. How can I have knowledgeable recall if I didn't have knowledge? It's all retrospective. All I can do is integrate my recollections with modern findings.

自我生命的审视。一层层的推敲,最后发现“我的全部努力不过完成了普通的生活”。

J: At first I thought there was something wrong with me. Maybe I was a bad guy for not dying. Then I began to wonder if I was cursed or perhaps blessed. Then I thought maybe I had a mission.

X: Do you still think you do? God works in mysterious ways.

J: I think I just happened.

男主角的定位其实一直很准,他并不是天才,只是活得够久见得够多了。就像之前看锵锵三人行王蒙张口就来30,40年代的北平。对我来说那是传奇的历史,对他来讲只是经历的生活。

总结整个影片,其实就是在告诉我们,观察并思考周围所有的事情,一切皆有可能。

但是,这个想法是自古就有,人类在历史发展中发现、总结、传承下来的;还是有一个哲学家或者科学家有一天产生这个想法并慢慢为大众所知;亦或是在某一个特定的时间,某个特别的人、团体、政府在人群中广泛散播这个想法,这样慢慢地使人们会接受一些之前完全无法认同的想法。当然,最后这个听起来太阴谋论了。但是谁又知道真实或者客观存在到底是什么呢?有可能从登月,太空站,火星探测开始,慢慢地我们也会接受、承认并感知到外星人、幽灵和四维空间。而我,由衷地希望,有一天我们不是必须要用科学去解释一些我们理解不了的玄学,或许量子力学和不用维度的空间同幽灵鬼怪等未知生物根本无关,而牛顿晚年的探索才是宇宙的真相。毕竟,一切皆有可能,不是吗?

0
0

查看更多豆瓣高分电影电视剧

回应(0)

添加回应

这个男人来自地球的更多影评

推荐这个男人来自地球的豆列

了解更多电影信息

豆瓣
免费下载 iOS / Android 版客户端