敦刻尔克 敦刻尔克 8.6分

Some thoughts

Lerota

Best editing and sound effect-makes sense. Three different, narrower perspectives to portray the vastness of this hot mess. And it's not just for the sake of it. You could see closely that how exactly these people survive and how much did they put through from their own very intense, traumatic experience, yet from another one's perspective, it looks so remote and trivial, nothing much more than defeat. That's what is horrifying about war: a huge collective traumatic experience that nobody other than you own really knows what happened and how do you feel, although you fight and helped with each other. The pilot could only saw there was a ship going down, the soldier only knows there were only one plane left to protect them, the civilian only knows those soldiers are dying and they should help them retreat. But the personal, intimate horror? Nobody else really knows. The best part of this one, was that it showed us how intense was each individual's experience, yet it showed us anot...

显示全文

Best editing and sound effect-makes sense. Three different, narrower perspectives to portray the vastness of this hot mess. And it's not just for the sake of it. You could see closely that how exactly these people survive and how much did they put through from their own very intense, traumatic experience, yet from another one's perspective, it looks so remote and trivial, nothing much more than defeat. That's what is horrifying about war: a huge collective traumatic experience that nobody other than you own really knows what happened and how do you feel, although you fight and helped with each other. The pilot could only saw there was a ship going down, the soldier only knows there were only one plane left to protect them, the civilian only knows those soldiers are dying and they should help them retreat. But the personal, intimate horror? Nobody else really knows. The best part of this one, was that it showed us how intense was each individual's experience, yet it showed us another "common" angle that tons of thousands of these were happening that it almost looks nothing of one. There was no win, there was no glory, there was cowardice, lies and suspicion but survive-that's the only thing that matters. There was excitement, there was heroic behavior, but all come out of natural response, not the normal overdone emotional manipulation. So yes, this is a fairly experimental, immersive and powerful experience that's done properly, with some little flaws but still a great work.

0
0

查看更多豆瓣高分电影电视剧

回应(0)

添加回应

敦刻尔克的更多影评

推荐敦刻尔克的豆列

提到这部电影的日记

了解更多电影信息

值得一读

    豆瓣
    我们的精神角落
    免费下载 iOS / Android 版客户端
    App 内打开