>
英语专业 英语专业 171104英语人才

看看美国教授布置的小作业

luka 2010-07-24
求帮助 暑期学校 题目都看不懂

During our visit to PETA, Bruce Friedrich referred a number of times to what
could variously be interpreted as a moral principle, standard, or test. One might
state it thusly (PETA may or may not want it stated thusly – but this is at least one
way of understanding what Bruce said):



If you wouldn’t do x yourself, then it’s wrong for you to pay someone else to do x for
you.



This principle was used to generate the conclusion that, for example, you shouldn’t
buy chicken meat, since you yourself wouldn’t butcher a chicken.
First, develop an objection to the use of this principle as a way of generating
conclusions such as the one given. Make the objection as compelling as possible.
Second, anticipate a likely response to your objection on behalf of PETA – a response
could either defend the principle as such or refine the principle to accommodate and
evade the point of the objection. Third, assess how the argument, after objection
and response, comes...
求帮助 暑期学校 题目都看不懂

During our visit to PETA, Bruce Friedrich referred a number of times to what
could variously be interpreted as a moral principle, standard, or test. One might
state it thusly (PETA may or may not want it stated thusly – but this is at least one
way of understanding what Bruce said):



If you wouldn’t do x yourself, then it’s wrong for you to pay someone else to do x for
you.



This principle was used to generate the conclusion that, for example, you shouldn’t
buy chicken meat, since you yourself wouldn’t butcher a chicken.
First, develop an objection to the use of this principle as a way of generating
conclusions such as the one given. Make the objection as compelling as possible.
Second, anticipate a likely response to your objection on behalf of PETA – a response
could either defend the principle as such or refine the principle to accommodate and
evade the point of the objection. Third, assess how the argument, after objection
and response, comes out. Support whatever conclusion you come to. (600 words)
0
显示全文

查看更多有趣的豆瓣小组

回应

还没人回应,我来添加

更多相关帖子

推荐小组

值得一读

    豆瓣
    我们的精神角落
    免费下载 iOS / Android 版客户端