>
Jacob Tierney Jacob Tierney 28成员

le cinema Québécois, c'est blanc, blanc, blanc!

saturdaylou 2010-07-22
Jacob最近有点麻烦了 他本月初的时候接受了La Presse的采访 然后不知是嗨了还是怎样 兴头一上来就开始指责说“魁北克电影人过分自我中心 只拍法语片 完全忽视了英语母语人群和移民的文化需求” 然后又说他虽然从小说法语但始终觉得自己是outsider之类的

这篇采访是法语的 我用google翻译看的 囧
http://moncinema.cyberpresse.ca/nouvelles-et-critiques/nouvelles/article/11984-jacob-tierney-les-anglos-et-les-immigrants-sont-ignores.html?utm_categorieinterne=trafficdrivers&utm_contenuinterne=cyberpresse_B13b_cinema_807_section_POS2

精华就这两段:
Quebec society is extremely turned in on itself. our art and our culture shows only white francophones. anglophones and immigrants are ignored. they have no place in the québécois dream. it’s shameful.
I was born in Quebec, I speak French, but for the people, that doesn’t change anything: I will always be perceived as the outsider. some people tell me I can always move to Toronto, but I don’t want to go to Toronto! Montreal is home!

然后这篇采访一出来 魁北克电影圈就不太平了 有支持有反对 闹...
Jacob最近有点麻烦了 他本月初的时候接受了La Presse的采访 然后不知是嗨了还是怎样 兴头一上来就开始指责说“魁北克电影人过分自我中心 只拍法语片 完全忽视了英语母语人群和移民的文化需求” 然后又说他虽然从小说法语但始终觉得自己是outsider之类的

这篇采访是法语的 我用google翻译看的 囧
http://moncinema.cyberpresse.ca/nouvelles-et-critiques/nouvelles/article/11984-jacob-tierney-les-anglos-et-les-immigrants-sont-ignores.html?utm_categorieinterne=trafficdrivers&utm_contenuinterne=cyberpresse_B13b_cinema_807_section_POS2

精华就这两段:
Quebec society is extremely turned in on itself. our art and our culture shows only white francophones. anglophones and immigrants are ignored. they have no place in the québécois dream. it’s shameful.
I was born in Quebec, I speak French, but for the people, that doesn’t change anything: I will always be perceived as the outsider. some people tell me I can always move to Toronto, but I don’t want to go to Toronto! Montreal is home!

然后这篇采访一出来 魁北克电影圈就不太平了 有支持有反对 闹得蛮厉害的 都出专有名词"l'affaire Tierney controversy"了 囧

语气比较重的么就说他一年轻小(帅)导演 仗着爸爸是知名制片人就好嚣张了? 自己才导了两部片 虽然Trotsky电影节上蛮风光的 那就有资格大嘴一开炮轰魁北克电影圈了?

这事情发生的时候呢 Jay在US宣传[apprentice] 他说他回蒙特利尔一下飞机就有记者给他递报纸看这条新闻(囧 画面感好强) 然后看完气死了 帮Jacob说了一堆好话:
Jacob has my loyalty regardless of what he says. I'll always have his back. but this time I also happen to agree with him with every fibre of my being.
I think the gist of what he was saying was that Quebec cinema has to reflect Quebec now which it's not. I think it's incumbent of cinema of any country to represent the country and sometimes the old guard don't relinquish control too easily. this is an incredibly beautiful multicultural society and more so that it ever has been. but it always was. we just need to incorporate more voices. there are many different types of Quebec and movies should reflect that. and if they don't, I think that's lazy and a cop-out.

我很意外的 我一直觉得Jacob是乖乖牌唉~
不过从他18岁就迷上Trotsky来看 他肯定很左倾的... 而且和从小教育也有关系 他爸很关注这种"franco-anglo"的话题 所以他们父子讨论电影话题时肯定经常聊这块 然后Kevin和[bon cop, bad cop]最近也一起被拿出来说了又说
0
显示全文

查看更多有趣的豆瓣小组

回应 (6条) 只看楼主

  • cody
    啊 连bon cop bad cop也提出来啦 我去找找再老讨论
    不过其实 我觉得哦 jay这人也是有点左的嘛 怪不得他和jacob这么搭的
  • saturdaylou
    恩很讽刺的 因为bon cop bad cop是第一部反映这种franco-anglo冲突的喜剧电影
    也是加拿大最卖座电影 而且它在魁北克区圈的钱最多... 当时那帮影评人不要太买账哦 现在统统倒戈了 囧伐~
  • saturdaylou
    然后反他们的这帮里有个人叫Brendan Kelly 蒙特利尔蛮有名一记者 他前阵子刚给Jay写了篇软文宣传[apprentice] 结果一听说Jay是挺Jacob的 立刻来了一句:
    don't foget that his new movie [the sorcerer's apprentice] opens Wednesday, July 14. go see it so it makes even more money and helps Baruchel conquer the world.
    呃 这话讲出来有点幼稚哦~
  • cody
    你说xavier dolan是站在哪一边的啊? =∇=
  • saturdaylou
    不知啊
    但他没事把电影往种族里扯 是有点欠考虑 唉还年轻啊...
  • saturdaylou
    http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/arts/tiff/news-and-features/jacob-tierneys-unneighbourly-conduct/article1705932/
    这篇写得很好 里面还提到些关于这事件的后续 一些他的回应
    还蛮会挑时间发表的嘛 明天[good neighbours] permiere 目前出来的review都挺正面的
添加回应

推荐小组

值得一读

    豆瓣
    我们的精神角落
    免费下载 iOS / Android 版客户端